Merge remote-tracking branch 'upstream/master' into isotp-parallel-response-pending

pull/24724/head
Shane Smiskol 3 years ago
commit 7fd8740374
  1. 38
      .github/workflows/selfdrive_tests.yaml
  2. 17
      Dockerfile.openpilot_base_cl
  3. 2
      cereal
  4. 1
      common/params.cc
  5. 82
      docs/CARS.md
  6. 2
      launch_env.sh
  7. 2
      panda
  8. 1
      selfdrive/car/body/interface.py
  9. 2
      selfdrive/car/body/values.py
  10. 18
      selfdrive/car/car_helpers.py
  11. 8
      selfdrive/car/chrysler/interface.py
  12. 28
      selfdrive/car/docs.py
  13. 11
      selfdrive/car/docs_definitions.py
  14. 40
      selfdrive/car/fingerprints.py
  15. 21
      selfdrive/car/fw_versions.py
  16. 2
      selfdrive/car/gm/interface.py
  17. 13
      selfdrive/car/honda/interface.py
  18. 12
      selfdrive/car/hyundai/interface.py
  19. 35
      selfdrive/car/interfaces.py
  20. 2
      selfdrive/car/isotp_parallel_query.py
  21. 2
      selfdrive/car/subaru/interface.py
  22. 6
      selfdrive/car/subaru/values.py
  23. 2
      selfdrive/car/tests/test_docs.py
  24. 21
      selfdrive/car/tests/test_fw_fingerprint.py
  25. 30
      selfdrive/car/toyota/interface.py
  26. 2
      selfdrive/car/toyota/tunes.py
  27. 1
      selfdrive/car/toyota/values.py
  28. 6
      selfdrive/car/volkswagen/interface.py
  29. 2
      selfdrive/controls/lib/latcontrol_torque.py
  30. 2
      selfdrive/controls/plannerd.py
  31. 6
      selfdrive/hardware/tici/agnos.json
  32. 6
      selfdrive/hardware/tici/test_power_draw.py
  33. 12
      selfdrive/locationd/laikad.py
  34. 2
      selfdrive/manager/build.py
  35. 14
      selfdrive/navd/helpers.py
  36. 41
      selfdrive/navd/navd.py
  37. 53
      selfdrive/test/process_replay/model_replay.py
  38. 2
      selfdrive/test/process_replay/ref_commit
  39. 9
      selfdrive/ui/qt/offroad/settings.cc
  40. 29
      selfdrive/ui/qt/onroad.cc
  41. 3
      selfdrive/ui/ui.cc
  42. 2
      selfdrive/ui/ui.h
  43. 15
      tools/sim/Dockerfile.sim

@ -362,6 +362,44 @@ jobs:
CI=1 AZURE_TOKEN='$AZURE_TOKEN' python selfdrive/test/process_replay/test_processes.py -j$(nproc) --upload-only" CI=1 AZURE_TOKEN='$AZURE_TOKEN' python selfdrive/test/process_replay/test_processes.py -j$(nproc) --upload-only"
- name: "Upload coverage to Codecov" - name: "Upload coverage to Codecov"
uses: codecov/codecov-action@v2 uses: codecov/codecov-action@v2
model_replay_onnx:
name: model replay onnx
runs-on: ubuntu-20.04
timeout-minutes: 50
steps:
- uses: actions/checkout@v3
with:
submodules: true
- name: Pull LFS
run: git lfs pull
- name: Cache dependencies
id: dependency-cache
uses: actions/cache@v2
with:
path: /tmp/comma_download_cache
key: ${{ hashFiles('.github/workflows/selfdrive_tests.yaml', 'selfdrive/test/process_replay/model_replay.py') }}
- name: Cache scons
id: scons-cache
# TODO: Change the version to the released version when https://github.com/actions/cache/pull/489 (or 571) is merged.
uses: actions/cache@03e00da99d75a2204924908e1cca7902cafce66b
env:
CACHE_SKIP_SAVE: true
with:
path: /tmp/scons_cache
key: scons-${{ hashFiles('.github/workflows/selfdrive_tests.yaml') }}-
restore-keys: |
scons-${{ hashFiles('.github/workflows/selfdrive_tests.yaml') }}-
scons-
- name: Build Docker image
# Sim docker is needed to get the intel OPENCL drivers
run: eval "$BUILD_CL"
- name: Run replay
run: |
${{ env.RUN_CL }} "scons -j$(nproc) && \
ONNXCPU=1 FILEREADER_CACHE=1 CI=1 coverage run \
selfdrive/test/process_replay/model_replay.py -j$(nproc) && \
coverage xml"
test_longitudinal: test_longitudinal:
name: longitudinal name: longitudinal

@ -1,7 +1,18 @@
FROM ghcr.io/commaai/openpilot-base:latest FROM ghcr.io/commaai/openpilot-base:latest
RUN apt-get update && apt-get install -y --no-install-recommends\ RUN apt-get update && apt-get install -y --no-install-recommends\
apt-utils \
alien \ alien \
unzip \
tar \
curl \
xz-utils \
dbus \
gcc-arm-none-eabi \
tmux \
vim \
lsb-core \
libx11-6 \
&& rm -rf /var/lib/apt/lists/* && rm -rf /var/lib/apt/lists/*
# Intel OpenCL driver # Intel OpenCL driver
@ -18,3 +29,9 @@ RUN echo INTEL_DRIVER is $INTEL_DRIVER && \
mkdir -p /etc/OpenCL/vendors && \ mkdir -p /etc/OpenCL/vendors && \
echo /opt/intel/opencl_compilers_and_libraries_18.1.0.015/linux/compiler/lib/intel64_lin/libintelocl.so > /etc/OpenCL/vendors/intel.icd && \ echo /opt/intel/opencl_compilers_and_libraries_18.1.0.015/linux/compiler/lib/intel64_lin/libintelocl.so > /etc/OpenCL/vendors/intel.icd && \
rm -rf /tmp/opencl-driver-intel rm -rf /tmp/opencl-driver-intel
ENV NVIDIA_VISIBLE_DEVICES all
ENV NVIDIA_DRIVER_CAPABILITIES graphics,utility,compute
ENV QTWEBENGINE_DISABLE_SANDBOX 1
RUN dbus-uuidgen > /etc/machine-id

@ -1 +1 @@
Subproject commit 6ad4ba689c557ed241862d10aef4235d3e96331f Subproject commit 7cbb4f1c8cb7cfc798a058c611801442b40feb52

@ -104,7 +104,6 @@ std::unordered_map<std::string, uint32_t> keys = {
{"DoReboot", CLEAR_ON_MANAGER_START}, {"DoReboot", CLEAR_ON_MANAGER_START},
{"DoShutdown", CLEAR_ON_MANAGER_START}, {"DoShutdown", CLEAR_ON_MANAGER_START},
{"DoUninstall", CLEAR_ON_MANAGER_START}, {"DoUninstall", CLEAR_ON_MANAGER_START},
{"EndToEndToggle", PERSISTENT},
{"ForcePowerDown", CLEAR_ON_MANAGER_START}, {"ForcePowerDown", CLEAR_ON_MANAGER_START},
{"GitBranch", PERSISTENT}, {"GitBranch", PERSISTENT},
{"GitCommit", PERSISTENT}, {"GitCommit", PERSISTENT},

@ -51,13 +51,7 @@ How We Rate The Cars
|Lexus|ES 2019-21|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Lexus|ES 2019-21|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|ES Hybrid 2019-22|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Lexus|ES Hybrid 2019-22|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|NX 2020|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Lexus|NX 2020|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|RX 2020-22|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|RX Hybrid 2020-21|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|UX Hybrid 2019-21|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Lexus|UX Hybrid 2019-21|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Alphard 2019-20|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Alphard Hybrid 2021|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Avalon 2022|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Avalon Hybrid 2022|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Camry 2021-22|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>4</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|Camry 2021-22|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>4</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Camry Hybrid 2021-22|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|Camry Hybrid 2021-22|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Corolla 2020-22|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|Corolla 2020-22|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
@ -75,12 +69,7 @@ How We Rate The Cars
|Make|Model|Supported Package|openpilot ACC|Stop and Go|Steer to 0|Steering Torque|Actively Maintained| |Make|Model|Supported Package|openpilot ACC|Stop and Go|Steer to 0|Steering Torque|Actively Maintained|
|---|---|---|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:| |---|---|---|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|
|Audi|A3 2014-19|ACC + Lane Assist|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Audi|A3 Sportback e-tron 2017-18|ACC + Lane Assist|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Audi|Q2 2018|ACC + Lane Assist|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Audi|Q2 2018|ACC + Lane Assist|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Audi|Q3 2020-21|ACC + Lane Assist|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Audi|RS3 2018|ACC + Lane Assist|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Audi|S3 2015-17|ACC + Lane Assist|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Genesis|G70 2018|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Genesis|G70 2018|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Genesis|G80 2018|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Genesis|G80 2018|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Hyundai|Elantra 2021-22|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Hyundai|Elantra 2021-22|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
@ -94,7 +83,6 @@ How We Rate The Cars
|Hyundai|Santa Fe 2021-22|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Hyundai|Santa Fe 2021-22|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Hyundai|Santa Fe Hybrid 2022|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Hyundai|Santa Fe Hybrid 2022|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Hyundai|Santa Fe Plug-in Hybrid 2022|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Hyundai|Santa Fe Plug-in Hybrid 2022|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Hyundai|Sonata 2018-19|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Hyundai|Tucson Diesel 2019|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Hyundai|Tucson Diesel 2019|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Kia|Ceed 2019|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Kia|Ceed 2019|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Kia|Forte 2018|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Kia|Forte 2018|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
@ -107,18 +95,15 @@ How We Rate The Cars
|Kia|Sorento 2018|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Kia|Sorento 2018|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Kia|Sorento 2019|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Kia|Sorento 2019|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Kia|Stinger 2018|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Kia|Stinger 2018|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|CT Hybrid 2017-18|LSS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|ES Hybrid 2017-18|LSS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Lexus|ES Hybrid 2017-18|LSS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|NX 2018-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Lexus|NX 2018-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|NX Hybrid 2018-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Lexus|NX Hybrid 2018-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|RX 2016-18|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Lexus|RX 2020-22|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|RX Hybrid 2016-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Lexus|RX Hybrid 2020-21|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Mazda|CX-5 2022|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Mazda|CX-5 2022|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|SEAT|Ateca 2018|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |SEAT|Ateca 2018|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|SEAT|Leon 2014-20|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |SEAT|Leon 2014-20|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Subaru|Crosstrek 2018-19|EyeSight|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Subaru|Forester 2019-21|EyeSight|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Subaru|Forester 2019-21|EyeSight|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Subaru|Impreza 2017-19|EyeSight|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Škoda|Kamiq 2021[<sup>6</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Škoda|Kamiq 2021[<sup>6</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Škoda|Karoq 2019|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Škoda|Karoq 2019|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Škoda|Kodiaq 2018-19|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Škoda|Kodiaq 2018-19|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
@ -126,36 +111,20 @@ How We Rate The Cars
|Škoda|Octavia RS 2016|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Škoda|Octavia RS 2016|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Škoda|Scala 2020|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Škoda|Scala 2020|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Škoda|Superb 2015-18|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Škoda|Superb 2015-18|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Avalon 2019-21|TSS-P|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|Alphard 2019-20|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Avalon Hybrid 2019-21|TSS-P|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|Alphard Hybrid 2021|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|C-HR 2017-21|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|Avalon 2022|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|C-HR Hybrid 2017-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|Avalon Hybrid 2022|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Camry 2018-20|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>4</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|Camry 2018-20|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>4</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Camry Hybrid 2018-20|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>4</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|Camry Hybrid 2018-20|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>4</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Highlander 2017-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Highlander Hybrid 2017-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|RAV4 2022|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|RAV4 2022|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|RAV4 Hybrid 2016-18|TSS-P|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|RAV4 Hybrid 2022|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|RAV4 Hybrid 2022|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Sienna 2018-20|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Arteon 2018, 2021[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Volkswagen|Arteon 2018, 2021[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Atlas 2018-19, 2022[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|e-Golf 2014, 2018-20|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Golf 2015-20|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Golf Alltrack 2017-18|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Golf GTE 2016|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Golf GTI 2018-21|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Golf R 2016-19|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Golf SportsVan 2016|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Golf SportWagen 2015|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Jetta 2018-21|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Jetta GLI 2021|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Passat 2015-18[<sup>7</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Volkswagen|Passat 2015-18[<sup>7</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Polo 2020|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Volkswagen|Polo 2020|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|T-Cross 2021[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Volkswagen|T-Cross 2021[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|T-Roc 2021[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Volkswagen|T-Roc 2021[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Taos 2022[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Volkswagen|Taos 2022[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Tiguan 2019-22[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Touran 2017|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Volkswagen|Touran 2017|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
## Bronze Cars ## Bronze Cars
@ -165,6 +134,11 @@ How We Rate The Cars
|Acura|ILX 2016-19|AcuraWatch Plus|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Acura|ILX 2016-19|AcuraWatch Plus|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Acura|RDX 2016-18|AcuraWatch Plus|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Acura|RDX 2016-18|AcuraWatch Plus|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Acura|RDX 2019-21|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Acura|RDX 2019-21|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Audi|A3 2014-19|ACC + Lane Assist|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Audi|A3 Sportback e-tron 2017-18|ACC + Lane Assist|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Audi|Q3 2020-21|ACC + Lane Assist|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Audi|RS3 2018|ACC + Lane Assist|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Audi|S3 2015-17|ACC + Lane Assist|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Cadillac|Escalade ESV 2016[<sup>1</sup>](#footnotes)|ACC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Cadillac|Escalade ESV 2016[<sup>1</sup>](#footnotes)|ACC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Chevrolet|Volt 2017-18[<sup>1</sup>](#footnotes)|Adaptive Cruise|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Chevrolet|Volt 2017-18[<sup>1</sup>](#footnotes)|Adaptive Cruise|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Chrysler|Pacifica 2017-18|Adaptive Cruise|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Chrysler|Pacifica 2017-18|Adaptive Cruise|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
@ -196,29 +170,55 @@ How We Rate The Cars
|Hyundai|Ioniq Electric 2019|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Hyundai|Ioniq Electric 2019|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Hyundai|Ioniq Hybrid 2017-19|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Hyundai|Ioniq Hybrid 2017-19|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Hyundai|Ioniq Plug-in Hybrid 2019|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Hyundai|Ioniq Plug-in Hybrid 2019|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Hyundai|Sonata 2018-19|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Hyundai|Veloster 2019-20|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Hyundai|Veloster 2019-20|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Jeep|Grand Cherokee 2016-18|Adaptive Cruise|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Jeep|Grand Cherokee 2016-18|Adaptive Cruise|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Jeep|Grand Cherokee 2019-20|Adaptive Cruise|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Jeep|Grand Cherokee 2019-20|Adaptive Cruise|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Kia|Niro Plug-in Hybrid 2019|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Kia|Niro Plug-in Hybrid 2019|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Kia|Optima 2017|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Kia|Optima 2017|SCC + LKAS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|IS 2017-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Lexus|CT Hybrid 2017-18|LSS|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|RC 2020|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Lexus|IS 2017-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|RC 2020|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|RX 2016-18|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Lexus|RX Hybrid 2016-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Mazda|CX-9 2021|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Mazda|CX-9 2021|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Nissan|Altima 2019-20|ProPILOT|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Nissan|Altima 2019-20|ProPILOT|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Nissan|Leaf 2018-22|ProPILOT|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Nissan|Leaf 2018-22|ProPILOT|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Nissan|Rogue 2018-20|ProPILOT|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Nissan|Rogue 2018-20|ProPILOT|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Nissan|X-Trail 2017|ProPILOT|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Nissan|X-Trail 2017|ProPILOT|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Subaru|Ascent 2019-20|EyeSight|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Subaru|Ascent 2019-20|EyeSight|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Subaru|Crosstrek 2018-19|EyeSight|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Subaru|Crosstrek 2020-21|EyeSight|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Subaru|Crosstrek 2020-21|EyeSight|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Subaru|Impreza 2017-19|EyeSight|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Subaru|Impreza 2020-21|EyeSight|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Subaru|Impreza 2020-21|EyeSight|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Avalon 2016-18|TSS-P|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|Avalon 2016-18|TSS-P|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Avalon 2019-21|TSS-P|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Avalon Hybrid 2019-21|TSS-P|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|C-HR 2017-21|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|C-HR Hybrid 2017-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Corolla 2017-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|Corolla 2017-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Highlander 2017-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Highlander Hybrid 2017-19|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Prius 2016-20|TSS-P|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>5</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|Prius 2016-20|TSS-P|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>5</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Prius Prime 2017-20|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>5</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|Prius Prime 2017-20|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>5</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Prius v 2017|TSS-P|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>5</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|Prius v 2017|TSS-P|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>5</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|RAV4 2016-18|TSS-P|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Toyota|RAV4 2016-18|TSS-P|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|RAV4 Hybrid 2016-18|TSS-P|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Toyota|Sienna 2018-20|All|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-half.svg" width="22" /></a>[<sup>3</sup>](#footnotes)|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Atlas 2018-19, 2022[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|California 2021[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Volkswagen|California 2021[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Caravelle 2020[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>| |Volkswagen|Caravelle 2020[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|e-Golf 2014, 2018-20|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Golf 2015-20|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Golf Alltrack 2017-18|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Golf GTE 2016|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Golf GTI 2018-21|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Golf R 2016-19|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Golf SportsVan 2016|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Golf SportWagen 2015|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Jetta 2018-21|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Jetta GLI 2021|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
|Volkswagen|Tiguan 2019-22[<sup>8</sup>](#footnotes)|Driver Assistance|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-empty.svg" width="22" /></a>|<a href="##"><img valign="top" src="assets/icon-star-full.svg" width="22" /></a>|
<a id="footnotes"></a> <a id="footnotes"></a>

@ -7,7 +7,7 @@ export OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS=1
export VECLIB_MAXIMUM_THREADS=1 export VECLIB_MAXIMUM_THREADS=1
if [ -z "$AGNOS_VERSION" ]; then if [ -z "$AGNOS_VERSION" ]; then
export AGNOS_VERSION="5" export AGNOS_VERSION="5.1"
fi fi
if [ -z "$PASSIVE" ]; then if [ -z "$PASSIVE" ]; then

@ -1 +1 @@
Subproject commit 6d19b46ef525b0ae224e0bf7db71918e96f9be66 Subproject commit 475a9a312410908abcaa32f2e48140fcbfc2362f

@ -17,6 +17,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.safetyConfigs = [get_safety_config(car.CarParams.SafetyModel.body)] ret.safetyConfigs = [get_safety_config(car.CarParams.SafetyModel.body)]
ret.minSteerSpeed = -math.inf ret.minSteerSpeed = -math.inf
ret.maxLateralAccel = math.inf # TODO: set to a reasonable value
ret.steerRatio = 0.5 ret.steerRatio = 0.5
ret.steerRateCost = 0.5 ret.steerRateCost = 0.5
ret.steerLimitTimer = 1.0 ret.steerLimitTimer = 1.0

@ -18,7 +18,7 @@ class CAR:
BODY = "COMMA BODY" BODY = "COMMA BODY"
CAR_INFO: Dict[str, CarInfo] = { CAR_INFO: Dict[str, CarInfo] = {
CAR.BODY: CarInfo("comma body", package="All", good_torque=True, harness=Harness.none), CAR.BODY: CarInfo("comma body", package="All", harness=Harness.none),
} }
FW_VERSIONS = { FW_VERSIONS = {

@ -1,9 +1,11 @@
import os import os
from typing import Any, Dict, List from typing import Dict, List
from cereal import car
from common.params import Params from common.params import Params
from common.basedir import BASEDIR from common.basedir import BASEDIR
from selfdrive.version import is_comma_remote, is_tested_branch from selfdrive.version import is_comma_remote, is_tested_branch
from selfdrive.car.interfaces import get_interface_attr
from selfdrive.car.fingerprints import eliminate_incompatible_cars, all_legacy_fingerprint_cars from selfdrive.car.fingerprints import eliminate_incompatible_cars, all_legacy_fingerprint_cars
from selfdrive.car.vin import get_vin, VIN_UNKNOWN from selfdrive.car.vin import get_vin, VIN_UNKNOWN
from selfdrive.car.fw_versions import get_fw_versions, match_fw_to_car from selfdrive.car.fw_versions import get_fw_versions, match_fw_to_car
@ -11,7 +13,6 @@ from selfdrive.swaglog import cloudlog
import cereal.messaging as messaging import cereal.messaging as messaging
from selfdrive.car import gen_empty_fingerprint from selfdrive.car import gen_empty_fingerprint
from cereal import car
EventName = car.CarEvent.EventName EventName = car.CarEvent.EventName
@ -59,19 +60,6 @@ def load_interfaces(brand_names):
return ret return ret
def get_interface_attr(attr: str) -> Dict[str, Any]:
# returns given attribute from each interface
brand_names = {}
for car_folder in sorted([x[0] for x in os.walk(BASEDIR + '/selfdrive/car')]):
try:
brand_name = car_folder.split('/')[-1]
attr_data = getattr(__import__(f'selfdrive.car.{brand_name}.values', fromlist=[attr]), attr, None)
brand_names[brand_name] = attr_data
except (ImportError, OSError):
pass
return brand_names
def _get_interface_names() -> Dict[str, List[str]]: def _get_interface_names() -> Dict[str, List[str]]:
# returns a dict of brand name and its respective models # returns a dict of brand name and its respective models
brand_names = {} brand_names = {}

@ -23,6 +23,14 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRateCost = 0.7 ret.steerRateCost = 0.7
ret.steerLimitTimer = 0.4 ret.steerLimitTimer = 0.4
# set max lateral acceleration
if candidate in (CAR.PACIFICA_2018, CAR.PACIFICA_2019_HYBRID, CAR.JEEP_CHEROKEE, CAR.JEEP_CHEROKEE_2019):
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.6
if candidate in (CAR.PACIFICA_2018_HYBRID,):
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.4
if candidate in (CAR.PACIFICA_2017_HYBRID,):
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.2
if candidate in (CAR.JEEP_CHEROKEE, CAR.JEEP_CHEROKEE_2019): if candidate in (CAR.JEEP_CHEROKEE, CAR.JEEP_CHEROKEE_2019):
ret.wheelbase = 2.91 # in meters ret.wheelbase = 2.91 # in meters
ret.steerRatio = 12.7 ret.steerRatio = 12.7

@ -15,9 +15,8 @@ from selfdrive.car.tests.routes import non_tested_cars
def get_all_footnotes() -> Dict[Enum, int]: def get_all_footnotes() -> Dict[Enum, int]:
all_footnotes = [] all_footnotes = []
for _, footnotes in get_interface_attr("Footnote").items(): for footnotes in get_interface_attr("Footnote", ignore_none=True).values():
if footnotes is not None: all_footnotes += footnotes
all_footnotes += footnotes
return {fn: idx + 1 for idx, fn in enumerate(all_footnotes)} return {fn: idx + 1 for idx, fn in enumerate(all_footnotes)}
@ -28,21 +27,20 @@ CARS_MD_TEMPLATE = os.path.join(BASEDIR, "selfdrive", "car", "CARS_template.md")
def get_all_car_info() -> List[CarInfo]: def get_all_car_info() -> List[CarInfo]:
all_car_info: List[CarInfo] = [] all_car_info: List[CarInfo] = []
for models in get_interface_attr("CAR_INFO").values(): for model, car_info in get_interface_attr("CAR_INFO", combine_brands=True).items():
for model, car_info in models.items(): # Hyundai exception: those with radar have openpilot longitudinal
# Hyundai exception: those with radar have openpilot longitudinal fingerprint = {0: {}, 1: {HKG_RADAR_START_ADDR: 8}, 2: {}, 3: {}}
fingerprint = {0: {}, 1: {HKG_RADAR_START_ADDR: 8}, 2: {}, 3: {}} CP = interfaces[model][0].get_params(model, fingerprint=fingerprint, disable_radar=True)
CP = interfaces[model][0].get_params(model, fingerprint=fingerprint, disable_radar=True)
if CP.dashcamOnly or car_info is None: if CP.dashcamOnly or car_info is None:
continue continue
# A platform can include multiple car models # A platform can include multiple car models
if not isinstance(car_info, list): if not isinstance(car_info, list):
car_info = (car_info,) car_info = (car_info,)
for _car_info in car_info: for _car_info in car_info:
all_car_info.append(_car_info.init(CP, non_tested_cars, ALL_FOOTNOTES)) all_car_info.append(_car_info.init(CP, non_tested_cars, ALL_FOOTNOTES))
# Sort cars by make and model + year # Sort cars by make and model + year
sorted_cars: List[CarInfo] = natsorted(all_car_info, key=lambda car: (car.make + car.model).lower()) sorted_cars: List[CarInfo] = natsorted(all_car_info, key=lambda car: (car.make + car.model).lower())

@ -1,9 +1,13 @@
import math
from cereal import car from cereal import car
from collections import namedtuple from collections import namedtuple
from dataclasses import dataclass from dataclasses import dataclass
from enum import Enum from enum import Enum
from typing import Dict, List, Optional, Union, no_type_check from typing import Dict, List, Optional, Union, no_type_check
STEERING_TORQUE_THRESHOLD = 2.0 # m/s^2
class Tier(Enum): class Tier(Enum):
GOLD = "The best openpilot experience. Great highway driving and beyond." GOLD = "The best openpilot experience. Great highway driving and beyond."
@ -66,6 +70,11 @@ class CarInfo:
if self.min_enable_speed is not None: if self.min_enable_speed is not None:
min_enable_speed = self.min_enable_speed min_enable_speed = self.min_enable_speed
# TODO: remove hardcoded good torque and just use maxLateralAccel
good_torque = self.good_torque
if not math.isnan(CP.maxLateralAccel):
good_torque = CP.maxLateralAccel >= STEERING_TORQUE_THRESHOLD
self.car_name = CP.carName self.car_name = CP.carName
self.make, self.model = self.name.split(' ', 1) self.make, self.model = self.name.split(' ', 1)
self.row = { self.row = {
@ -76,7 +85,7 @@ class CarInfo:
Column.LONGITUDINAL: CP.openpilotLongitudinalControl and not CP.radarOffCan, Column.LONGITUDINAL: CP.openpilotLongitudinalControl and not CP.radarOffCan,
Column.FSR_LONGITUDINAL: min_enable_speed <= 0., Column.FSR_LONGITUDINAL: min_enable_speed <= 0.,
Column.FSR_STEERING: min_steer_speed <= 0., Column.FSR_STEERING: min_steer_speed <= 0.,
Column.STEERING_TORQUE: self.good_torque, Column.STEERING_TORQUE: good_torque,
Column.MAINTAINED: CP.carFingerprint not in non_tested_cars and self.harness is not Harness.none, Column.MAINTAINED: CP.carFingerprint not in non_tested_cars and self.harness is not Harness.none,
} }

@ -1,44 +1,12 @@
import os from selfdrive.car.interfaces import get_interface_attr
from common.basedir import BASEDIR
def get_attr_from_cars(attr, result=dict, combine_brands=True): FW_VERSIONS = get_interface_attr('FW_VERSIONS', combine_brands=True, ignore_none=True)
# read all the folders in selfdrive/car and return a dict where: _FINGERPRINTS = get_interface_attr('FINGERPRINTS', combine_brands=True, ignore_none=True)
# - keys are all the car models
# - values are attr values from all car folders
result = result()
for car_folder in [x[0] for x in os.walk(BASEDIR + '/selfdrive/car')]:
try:
car_name = car_folder.split('/')[-1]
values = __import__(f'selfdrive.car.{car_name}.values', fromlist=[attr])
if hasattr(values, attr):
attr_values = getattr(values, attr)
else:
continue
if isinstance(attr_values, dict):
for f, v in attr_values.items():
if combine_brands:
result[f] = v
else:
if car_name not in result:
result[car_name] = {}
result[car_name][f] = v
elif isinstance(attr_values, list):
result += attr_values
except (ImportError, OSError):
pass
return result
FW_VERSIONS = get_attr_from_cars('FW_VERSIONS')
_FINGERPRINTS = get_attr_from_cars('FINGERPRINTS')
_DEBUG_ADDRESS = {1880: 8} # reserved for debug purposes _DEBUG_ADDRESS = {1880: 8} # reserved for debug purposes
def is_valid_for_fingerprint(msg, car_fingerprint): def is_valid_for_fingerprint(msg, car_fingerprint):
adr = msg.address adr = msg.address
# ignore addresses that are more than 11 bits # ignore addresses that are more than 11 bits

@ -1,15 +1,15 @@
#!/usr/bin/env python3 #!/usr/bin/env python3
import struct import struct
import traceback import traceback
from typing import Any, List
from collections import defaultdict from collections import defaultdict
from dataclasses import dataclass from dataclasses import dataclass, field
from typing import Any, List
from tqdm import tqdm from tqdm import tqdm
import panda.python.uds as uds import panda.python.uds as uds
from cereal import car from cereal import car
from selfdrive.car.fingerprints import FW_VERSIONS, get_attr_from_cars from selfdrive.car.interfaces import get_interface_attr
from selfdrive.car.fingerprints import FW_VERSIONS
from selfdrive.car.isotp_parallel_query import IsoTpParallelQuery from selfdrive.car.isotp_parallel_query import IsoTpParallelQuery
from selfdrive.car.toyota.values import CAR as TOYOTA from selfdrive.car.toyota.values import CAR as TOYOTA
from selfdrive.swaglog import cloudlog from selfdrive.swaglog import cloudlog
@ -96,9 +96,11 @@ class Request:
brand: str brand: str
request: List[bytes] request: List[bytes]
response: List[bytes] response: List[bytes]
whitelist_ecus: List[int] = field(default_factory=list)
rx_offset: int = DEFAULT_RX_OFFSET rx_offset: int = DEFAULT_RX_OFFSET
bus: int = 1 bus: int = 1
REQUESTS: List[Request] = [ REQUESTS: List[Request] = [
# Subaru # Subaru
Request( Request(
@ -303,7 +305,7 @@ def get_fw_versions(logcan, sendcan, extra=None, timeout=0.1, debug=False, progr
addrs = [] addrs = []
parallel_addrs = [] parallel_addrs = []
versions = get_attr_from_cars('FW_VERSIONS', combine_brands=False) versions = get_interface_attr('FW_VERSIONS', ignore_none=True)
if extra is not None: if extra is not None:
versions.update(extra) versions.update(extra)
@ -328,23 +330,26 @@ def get_fw_versions(logcan, sendcan, extra=None, timeout=0.1, debug=False, progr
for addr_chunk in chunks(addr): for addr_chunk in chunks(addr):
for r in REQUESTS: for r in REQUESTS:
try: try:
addrs = [(a, s) for (b, a, s) in addr_chunk if b in (r.brand, 'any')] addrs = [(a, s) for (b, a, s) in addr_chunk if b in (r.brand, 'any') and
(len(r.whitelist_ecus) == 0 or ecu_types[(a, s)] in r.whitelist_ecus)]
if addrs: if addrs:
query = IsoTpParallelQuery(sendcan, logcan, r.bus, addrs, r.request, r.response, r.rx_offset, debug=debug) query = IsoTpParallelQuery(sendcan, logcan, r.bus, addrs, r.request, r.response, r.rx_offset, debug=debug)
t = 2 * timeout if i == 0 else timeout t = 2 * timeout if i == 0 else timeout
fw_versions.update(query.get_data(t)) fw_versions.update({addr: (version, r.request, r.rx_offset) for addr, version in query.get_data(t).items()})
except Exception: except Exception:
cloudlog.warning(f"FW query exception: {traceback.format_exc()}") cloudlog.warning(f"FW query exception: {traceback.format_exc()}")
# Build capnp list to put into CarParams # Build capnp list to put into CarParams
car_fw = [] car_fw = []
for addr, version in fw_versions.items(): for addr, (version, request, rx_offset) in fw_versions.items():
f = car.CarParams.CarFw.new_message() f = car.CarParams.CarFw.new_message()
f.ecu = ecu_types[addr] f.ecu = ecu_types[addr]
f.fwVersion = version f.fwVersion = version
f.address = addr[0] f.address = addr[0]
f.responseAddress = addr[0] + rx_offset
f.request = request
if addr[1] is not None: if addr[1] is not None:
f.subAddress = addr[1] f.subAddress = addr[1]

@ -75,6 +75,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.469 # Stock Michelin Energy Saver A/S, LiveParameters tire_stiffness_factor = 0.469 # Stock Michelin Energy Saver A/S, LiveParameters
ret.steerRatioRear = 0. ret.steerRatioRear = 0.
ret.centerToFront = ret.wheelbase * 0.45 # Volt Gen 1, TODO corner weigh ret.centerToFront = ret.wheelbase * 0.45 # Volt Gen 1, TODO corner weigh
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.6
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [0., 40.] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [0., 40.]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV = [0., 0.17] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV = [0., 0.17]
@ -108,6 +109,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 14.4 # end to end is 13.46 ret.steerRatio = 14.4 # end to end is 13.46
ret.steerRatioRear = 0. ret.steerRatioRear = 0.
ret.centerToFront = ret.wheelbase * 0.4 ret.centerToFront = ret.wheelbase * 0.4
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.4
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kf = 1. # get_steer_feedforward_acadia() ret.lateralTuning.pid.kf = 1. # get_steer_feedforward_acadia()
elif candidate == CAR.BUICK_REGAL: elif candidate == CAR.BUICK_REGAL:

@ -100,6 +100,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 2560, 8000], [0, 2560, 3840]] ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 2560, 8000], [0, 2560, 3840]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.3], [0.1]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.3], [0.1]]
else: else:
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.7
ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 2560], [0, 2560]] ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 2560], [0, 2560]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[1.1], [0.33]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[1.1], [0.33]]
tire_stiffness_factor = 1. tire_stiffness_factor = 1.
@ -112,6 +113,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 15.38 # 10.93 is end-to-end spec ret.steerRatio = 15.38 # 10.93 is end-to-end spec
ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 4096], [0, 4096]] # TODO: determine if there is a dead zone at the top end ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 4096], [0, 4096]] # TODO: determine if there is a dead zone at the top end
tire_stiffness_factor = 1. tire_stiffness_factor = 1.
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.6
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.8], [0.24]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.8], [0.24]]
elif candidate in (CAR.ACCORD, CAR.ACCORDH): elif candidate in (CAR.ACCORD, CAR.ACCORDH):
@ -126,6 +128,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
if eps_modified: if eps_modified:
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.3], [0.09]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.3], [0.09]]
else: else:
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.6
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.6], [0.18]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.6], [0.18]]
elif candidate == CAR.ACURA_ILX: elif candidate == CAR.ACURA_ILX:
@ -162,6 +165,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 2560, 10000], [0, 2560, 3840]] ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 2560, 10000], [0, 2560, 3840]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.21], [0.07]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.21], [0.07]]
else: else:
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.7
ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 3840], [0, 3840]] ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 3840], [0, 3840]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.64], [0.192]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.64], [0.192]]
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.677 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.677
@ -186,6 +190,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 13.06 ret.steerRatio = 13.06
ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 4096], [0, 4096]] # TODO: determine if there is a dead zone at the top end ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 4096], [0, 4096]] # TODO: determine if there is a dead zone at the top end
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.75 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.75
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.7
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.2], [0.05]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.2], [0.05]]
elif candidate == CAR.FREED: elif candidate == CAR.FREED:
@ -216,8 +221,9 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.wheelbase = 2.68 ret.wheelbase = 2.68
ret.centerToFront = ret.wheelbase * 0.38 ret.centerToFront = ret.wheelbase * 0.38
ret.steerRatio = 15.0 # as spec ret.steerRatio = 15.0 # as spec
ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 1000], [0, 1000]] # TODO: determine if there is a dead zone at the top end
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444
ret.maxLateralAccel = 0.9
ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 1000], [0, 1000]] # TODO: determine if there is a dead zone at the top end
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.8], [0.24]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.8], [0.24]]
elif candidate == CAR.ACURA_RDX_3G: elif candidate == CAR.ACURA_RDX_3G:
@ -226,6 +232,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.wheelbase = 2.75 ret.wheelbase = 2.75
ret.centerToFront = ret.wheelbase * 0.41 ret.centerToFront = ret.wheelbase * 0.41
ret.steerRatio = 11.95 # as spec ret.steerRatio = 11.95 # as spec
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.2
ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 3840], [0, 3840]] ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 3840], [0, 3840]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.2], [0.06]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.2], [0.06]]
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.677 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.677
@ -238,6 +245,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 14.35 # as spec ret.steerRatio = 14.35 # as spec
ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 4096], [0, 4096]] # TODO: determine if there is a dead zone at the top end ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 4096], [0, 4096]] # TODO: determine if there is a dead zone at the top end
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.82 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.82
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.5
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.28], [0.08]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.28], [0.08]]
elif candidate == CAR.ODYSSEY_CHN: elif candidate == CAR.ODYSSEY_CHN:
@ -258,6 +266,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 17.25 # as spec ret.steerRatio = 17.25 # as spec
ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 4096], [0, 4096]] # TODO: determine if there is a dead zone at the top end ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 4096], [0, 4096]] # TODO: determine if there is a dead zone at the top end
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.5
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.38], [0.11]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.38], [0.11]]
elif candidate == CAR.RIDGELINE: elif candidate == CAR.RIDGELINE:
@ -268,6 +277,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 15.59 # as spec ret.steerRatio = 15.59 # as spec
ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 4096], [0, 4096]] # TODO: determine if there is a dead zone at the top end ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 4096], [0, 4096]] # TODO: determine if there is a dead zone at the top end
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.3
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.38], [0.11]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.38], [0.11]]
elif candidate == CAR.INSIGHT: elif candidate == CAR.INSIGHT:
@ -278,6 +288,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 15.0 # 12.58 is spec end-to-end ret.steerRatio = 15.0 # 12.58 is spec end-to-end
ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 4096], [0, 4096]] # TODO: determine if there is a dead zone at the top end ret.lateralParams.torqueBP, ret.lateralParams.torqueV = [[0, 4096], [0, 4096]] # TODO: determine if there is a dead zone at the top end
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.82 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.82
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.4
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.6], [0.18]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.6], [0.18]]
elif candidate == CAR.HONDA_E: elif candidate == CAR.HONDA_E:

@ -60,6 +60,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
# Values from optimizer # Values from optimizer
ret.steerRatio = 16.55 # 13.8 is spec end-to-end ret.steerRatio = 16.55 # 13.8 is spec end-to-end
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.82 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.82
ret.maxLateralAccel = 3.2
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[9., 22.], [9., 22.]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[9., 22.], [9., 22.]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.2, 0.35], [0.05, 0.09]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.2, 0.35], [0.05, 0.09]]
elif candidate in (CAR.SONATA, CAR.SONATA_HYBRID): elif candidate in (CAR.SONATA, CAR.SONATA_HYBRID):
@ -68,6 +69,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.wheelbase = 2.84 ret.wheelbase = 2.84
ret.steerRatio = 13.27 * 1.15 # 15% higher at the center seems reasonable ret.steerRatio = 13.27 * 1.15 # 15% higher at the center seems reasonable
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.65 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.65
ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.5
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0.], [0.]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0.], [0.]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.25], [0.05]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.25], [0.05]]
elif candidate == CAR.SONATA_LF: elif candidate == CAR.SONATA_LF:
@ -75,6 +77,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.mass = 4497. * CV.LB_TO_KG ret.mass = 4497. * CV.LB_TO_KG
ret.wheelbase = 2.804 ret.wheelbase = 2.804
ret.steerRatio = 13.27 * 1.15 # 15% higher at the center seems reasonable ret.steerRatio = 13.27 * 1.15 # 15% higher at the center seems reasonable
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.8
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0.], [0.]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0.], [0.]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.25], [0.05]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.25], [0.05]]
elif candidate == CAR.PALISADE: elif candidate == CAR.PALISADE:
@ -83,6 +86,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.wheelbase = 2.90 ret.wheelbase = 2.90
ret.steerRatio = 15.6 * 1.15 ret.steerRatio = 15.6 * 1.15
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.63 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.63
ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.5
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0.], [0.]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0.], [0.]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.3], [0.05]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.3], [0.05]]
elif candidate in (CAR.ELANTRA, CAR.ELANTRA_GT_I30): elif candidate in (CAR.ELANTRA, CAR.ELANTRA_GT_I30):
@ -139,6 +143,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.wheelbase = 2.7 ret.wheelbase = 2.7
ret.steerRatio = 13.73 # Spec ret.steerRatio = 13.73 # Spec
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.385 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.385
ret.maxLateralAccel = 3.0
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0.], [0.]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0.], [0.]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.25], [0.05]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.25], [0.05]]
if candidate not in (CAR.IONIQ_EV_2020, CAR.IONIQ_PHEV, CAR.IONIQ_HEV_2022): if candidate not in (CAR.IONIQ_EV_2020, CAR.IONIQ_PHEV, CAR.IONIQ_HEV_2022):
@ -188,6 +193,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.wheelbase = 2.7 ret.wheelbase = 2.7
ret.steerRatio = 13.9 if CAR.KIA_NIRO_HEV_2021 else 13.73 # Spec ret.steerRatio = 13.9 if CAR.KIA_NIRO_HEV_2021 else 13.73 # Spec
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.385 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.385
ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.9
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0.], [0.]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0.], [0.]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.25], [0.05]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.25], [0.05]]
if candidate == CAR.KIA_NIRO_HEV: if candidate == CAR.KIA_NIRO_HEV:
@ -219,6 +225,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.mass = 1825. + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 1825. + STD_CARGO_KG
ret.wheelbase = 2.78 ret.wheelbase = 2.78
ret.steerRatio = 14.4 * 1.15 # 15% higher at the center seems reasonable ret.steerRatio = 14.4 * 1.15 # 15% higher at the center seems reasonable
ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.4
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0.], [0.]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0.], [0.]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.25], [0.05]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.25], [0.05]]
elif candidate == CAR.KIA_FORTE: elif candidate == CAR.KIA_FORTE:
@ -244,6 +251,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.wheelbase = 2.85 ret.wheelbase = 2.85
ret.steerRatio = 13.27 # 2021 Kia K5 Steering Ratio (all trims) ret.steerRatio = 13.27 # 2021 Kia K5 Steering Ratio (all trims)
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.5 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.5
ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.1
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0.], [0.]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0.], [0.]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.25], [0.05]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.25], [0.05]]
elif candidate == CAR.KIA_EV6: elif candidate == CAR.KIA_EV6:
@ -254,8 +262,8 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
get_safety_config(car.CarParams.SafetyModel.hyundaiHDA2)] get_safety_config(car.CarParams.SafetyModel.hyundaiHDA2)]
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.65 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.65
max_lat_accel = 2. ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.
set_torque_tune(ret.lateralTuning, max_lat_accel, 0.01) set_torque_tune(ret.lateralTuning, ret.maxLateralAccel, 0.01)
# Genesis # Genesis
elif candidate == CAR.GENESIS_G70: elif candidate == CAR.GENESIS_G70:

@ -1,13 +1,14 @@
import os import os
import time import time
from abc import abstractmethod, ABC from abc import abstractmethod, ABC
from typing import Dict, Tuple, List from typing import Any, Dict, Tuple, List
from cereal import car from cereal import car
from common.basedir import BASEDIR
from common.conversions import Conversions as CV
from common.kalman.simple_kalman import KF1D from common.kalman.simple_kalman import KF1D
from common.realtime import DT_CTRL from common.realtime import DT_CTRL
from selfdrive.car import gen_empty_fingerprint from selfdrive.car import gen_empty_fingerprint
from common.conversions import Conversions as CV
from selfdrive.controls.lib.drive_helpers import V_CRUISE_MAX from selfdrive.controls.lib.drive_helpers import V_CRUISE_MAX
from selfdrive.controls.lib.events import Events from selfdrive.controls.lib.events import Events
from selfdrive.controls.lib.vehicle_model import VehicleModel from selfdrive.controls.lib.vehicle_model import VehicleModel
@ -22,7 +23,6 @@ ACCEL_MIN = -3.5
# generic car and radar interfaces # generic car and radar interfaces
class CarInterfaceBase(ABC): class CarInterfaceBase(ABC):
def __init__(self, CP, CarController, CarState): def __init__(self, CP, CarController, CarState):
self.CP = CP self.CP = CP
@ -81,6 +81,7 @@ class CarInterfaceBase(ABC):
ret.steerControlType = car.CarParams.SteerControlType.torque ret.steerControlType = car.CarParams.SteerControlType.torque
ret.minSteerSpeed = 0. ret.minSteerSpeed = 0.
ret.wheelSpeedFactor = 1.0 ret.wheelSpeedFactor = 1.0
ret.maxLateralAccel = float('nan')
ret.pcmCruise = True # openpilot's state is tied to the PCM's cruise state on most cars ret.pcmCruise = True # openpilot's state is tied to the PCM's cruise state on most cars
ret.minEnableSpeed = -1. # enable is done by stock ACC, so ignore this ret.minEnableSpeed = -1. # enable is done by stock ACC, so ignore this
@ -293,3 +294,31 @@ class CarStateBase(ABC):
@staticmethod @staticmethod
def get_loopback_can_parser(CP): def get_loopback_can_parser(CP):
return None return None
# interface-specific helpers
def get_interface_attr(attr: str, combine_brands: bool = False, ignore_none: bool = False) -> Dict[str, Any]:
# read all the folders in selfdrive/car and return a dict where:
# - keys are all the car models or brand names
# - values are attr values from all car folders
result = {}
for car_folder in sorted([x[0] for x in os.walk(BASEDIR + '/selfdrive/car')]):
try:
brand_name = car_folder.split('/')[-1]
brand_values = __import__(f'selfdrive.car.{brand_name}.values', fromlist=[attr])
if hasattr(brand_values, attr) or not ignore_none:
attr_data = getattr(brand_values, attr, None)
else:
continue
if combine_brands:
if isinstance(attr_data, dict):
for f, v in attr_data.items():
result[f] = v
else:
result[brand_name] = attr_data
except (ImportError, OSError):
pass
return result

@ -139,7 +139,7 @@ class IsoTpParallelQuery:
cloudlog.warning(f"iso-tp query response pending: {hex(tx_addr)}") cloudlog.warning(f"iso-tp query response pending: {hex(tx_addr)}")
else: else:
request_done[tx_addr] = True request_done[tx_addr] = True
cloudlog.warning(f"iso-tp query bad response: 0x{dat.hex()}") cloudlog.warning(f"iso-tp query bad response: {tx_addr} - 0x{dat.hex()}")
cur_time = time.monotonic() cur_time = time.monotonic()
if cur_time - max(response_timeouts.values()) > 0: if cur_time - max(response_timeouts.values()) > 0:

@ -51,6 +51,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.centerToFront = ret.wheelbase * 0.5 ret.centerToFront = ret.wheelbase * 0.5
ret.steerRatio = 17 # learned, 14 stock ret.steerRatio = 17 # learned, 14 stock
ret.steerActuatorDelay = 0.1 ret.steerActuatorDelay = 0.1
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.3
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kf = 0.00005 ret.lateralTuning.pid.kf = 0.00005
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0., 14., 23.], [0., 14., 23.]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0., 14., 23.], [0., 14., 23.]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.045, 0.042, 0.20], [0.04, 0.035, 0.045]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.045, 0.042, 0.20], [0.04, 0.035, 0.045]]
@ -61,6 +62,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.centerToFront = ret.wheelbase * 0.5 ret.centerToFront = ret.wheelbase * 0.5
ret.steerRatio = 17 # learned, 14 stock ret.steerRatio = 17 # learned, 14 stock
ret.steerActuatorDelay = 0.1 ret.steerActuatorDelay = 0.1
ret.maxLateralAccel = 3.2
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kf = 0.000038 ret.lateralTuning.pid.kf = 0.000038
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0., 14., 23.], [0., 14., 23.]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiBP, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpBP = [[0., 14., 23.], [0., 14., 23.]]
ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.01, 0.065, 0.2], [0.001, 0.015, 0.025]] ret.lateralTuning.pid.kpV, ret.lateralTuning.pid.kiV = [[0.01, 0.065, 0.2], [0.001, 0.015, 0.025]]

@ -43,14 +43,14 @@ class SubaruCarInfo(CarInfo):
CAR_INFO: Dict[str, Union[SubaruCarInfo, List[SubaruCarInfo]]] = { CAR_INFO: Dict[str, Union[SubaruCarInfo, List[SubaruCarInfo]]] = {
CAR.ASCENT: SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Ascent 2019-20"), CAR.ASCENT: SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Ascent 2019-20"),
CAR.IMPREZA: [ CAR.IMPREZA: [
SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Impreza 2017-19", good_torque=True), SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Impreza 2017-19"),
SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Crosstrek 2018-19", video_link="https://youtu.be/Agww7oE1k-s?t=26", good_torque=True), SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Crosstrek 2018-19", video_link="https://youtu.be/Agww7oE1k-s?t=26"),
], ],
CAR.IMPREZA_2020: [ CAR.IMPREZA_2020: [
SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Impreza 2020-21"), SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Impreza 2020-21"),
SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Crosstrek 2020-21"), SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Crosstrek 2020-21"),
], ],
CAR.FORESTER: SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Forester 2019-21", good_torque=True), CAR.FORESTER: SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Forester 2019-21"),
CAR.FORESTER_PREGLOBAL: SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Forester 2017-18"), CAR.FORESTER_PREGLOBAL: SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Forester 2017-18"),
CAR.LEGACY_PREGLOBAL: SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Legacy 2015-18"), CAR.LEGACY_PREGLOBAL: SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Legacy 2015-18"),
CAR.OUTBACK_PREGLOBAL: SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Outback 2015-17"), CAR.OUTBACK_PREGLOBAL: SubaruCarInfo("Subaru Outback 2015-17"),

@ -18,7 +18,7 @@ class TestCarDocs(unittest.TestCase):
"Run selfdrive/car/docs.py to generate new supported cars documentation") "Run selfdrive/car/docs.py to generate new supported cars documentation")
def test_missing_car_info(self): def test_missing_car_info(self):
all_car_info_platforms = [p for i in get_interface_attr("CAR_INFO").values() for p in i] all_car_info_platforms = get_interface_attr("CAR_INFO", combine_brands=True).keys()
for platform in sorted(interfaces.keys()): for platform in sorted(interfaces.keys()):
if platform not in all_car_info_platforms: if platform not in all_car_info_platforms:
self.fail("Platform: {} doesn't exist in CarInfo".format(platform)) self.fail("Platform: {} doesn't exist in CarInfo".format(platform))

@ -4,9 +4,9 @@ import unittest
from parameterized import parameterized from parameterized import parameterized
from cereal import car from cereal import car
from selfdrive.car.car_helpers import interfaces from selfdrive.car.car_helpers import get_interface_attr, interfaces
from selfdrive.car.fingerprints import FW_VERSIONS from selfdrive.car.fingerprints import FW_VERSIONS
from selfdrive.car.fw_versions import match_fw_to_car from selfdrive.car.fw_versions import REQUESTS, match_fw_to_car
CarFw = car.CarParams.CarFw CarFw = car.CarParams.CarFw
Ecu = car.CarParams.Ecu Ecu = car.CarParams.Ecu
@ -57,6 +57,23 @@ class TestFwFingerprint(unittest.TestCase):
self.assertTrue(passed, "Blacklisted FW versions found") self.assertTrue(passed, "Blacklisted FW versions found")
def test_fw_request_ecu_whitelist(self):
passed = True
brands = set(r.brand for r in REQUESTS)
versions = get_interface_attr('FW_VERSIONS')
for brand in brands:
whitelisted_ecus = [ecu for r in REQUESTS for ecu in r.whitelist_ecus if r.brand == brand]
brand_ecus = set([fw[0] for car_fw in versions[brand].values() for fw in car_fw])
# each ecu in brand's fw versions needs to be whitelisted at least once
ecus_not_whitelisted = set(brand_ecus) - set(whitelisted_ecus)
if len(whitelisted_ecus) and len(ecus_not_whitelisted):
ecu_strings = ", ".join([f'Ecu.{ECU_NAME[ecu]}' for ecu in ecus_not_whitelisted])
print(f'{brand.title()}: FW query whitelist missing ecus: {ecu_strings}')
passed = False
self.assertTrue(passed, "Not all ecus in FW versions found in query whitelists")
if __name__ == "__main__": if __name__ == "__main__":
unittest.main() unittest.main()

@ -38,7 +38,8 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 15.74 # unknown end-to-end spec ret.steerRatio = 15.74 # unknown end-to-end spec
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.6371 # hand-tune tire_stiffness_factor = 0.6371 # hand-tune
ret.mass = 3045. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 3045. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.TORQUE, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=1.7, FRICTION=0.06) ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.7
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.TORQUE, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=ret.maxLateralAccel, FRICTION=0.06)
elif candidate == CAR.PRIUS_V: elif candidate == CAR.PRIUS_V:
stop_and_go = True stop_and_go = True
@ -46,7 +47,8 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 17.4 ret.steerRatio = 17.4
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.5533 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.5533
ret.mass = 3340. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 3340. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.TORQUE, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=1.8, FRICTION=0.06) ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.8
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.TORQUE, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=ret.maxLateralAccel, FRICTION=0.06)
elif candidate in (CAR.RAV4, CAR.RAV4H): elif candidate in (CAR.RAV4, CAR.RAV4H):
stop_and_go = True if (candidate in CAR.RAV4H) else False stop_and_go = True if (candidate in CAR.RAV4H) else False
@ -54,14 +56,16 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 16.88 # 14.5 is spec end-to-end ret.steerRatio = 16.88 # 14.5 is spec end-to-end
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.5533 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.5533
ret.mass = 3650. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # mean between normal and hybrid ret.mass = 3650. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # mean between normal and hybrid
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.TORQUE, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=1.8, FRICTION=0.06) ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.8
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.TORQUE, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=ret.maxLateralAccel, FRICTION=0.06)
elif candidate == CAR.COROLLA: elif candidate == CAR.COROLLA:
ret.wheelbase = 2.70 ret.wheelbase = 2.70
ret.steerRatio = 18.27 ret.steerRatio = 18.27
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444 # not optimized yet tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444 # not optimized yet
ret.mass = 2860. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # mean between normal and hybrid ret.mass = 2860. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # mean between normal and hybrid
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.TORQUE, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=2.8, FRICTION=0.024) ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.8
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.TORQUE, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=ret.maxLateralAccel, FRICTION=0.024)
elif candidate in (CAR.LEXUS_RX, CAR.LEXUS_RXH, CAR.LEXUS_RX_TSS2, CAR.LEXUS_RXH_TSS2): elif candidate in (CAR.LEXUS_RX, CAR.LEXUS_RXH, CAR.LEXUS_RX_TSS2, CAR.LEXUS_RXH_TSS2):
stop_and_go = True stop_and_go = True
@ -70,6 +74,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.wheelSpeedFactor = 1.035 ret.wheelSpeedFactor = 1.035
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.5533 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.5533
ret.mass = 4481. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # mean between min and max ret.mass = 4481. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # mean between min and max
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.4
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_C) set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_C)
elif candidate in (CAR.CHR, CAR.CHRH): elif candidate in (CAR.CHR, CAR.CHRH):
@ -78,6 +83,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 13.6 ret.steerRatio = 13.6
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.7933 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.7933
ret.mass = 3300. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 3300. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.3
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_F) set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_F)
elif candidate in (CAR.CAMRY, CAR.CAMRYH, CAR.CAMRY_TSS2, CAR.CAMRYH_TSS2): elif candidate in (CAR.CAMRY, CAR.CAMRYH, CAR.CAMRY_TSS2, CAR.CAMRYH_TSS2):
@ -87,8 +93,10 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.7933 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.7933
ret.mass = 3400. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # mean between normal and hybrid ret.mass = 3400. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # mean between normal and hybrid
if candidate in (CAR.CAMRY_TSS2, CAR.CAMRYH_TSS2): if candidate in (CAR.CAMRY_TSS2, CAR.CAMRYH_TSS2):
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.TORQUE, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=2.4, FRICTION=0.05) ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.4
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.TORQUE, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=ret.maxLateralAccel, FRICTION=0.05)
else: else:
ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.0
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_C) set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_C)
elif candidate in (CAR.HIGHLANDER_TSS2, CAR.HIGHLANDERH_TSS2): elif candidate in (CAR.HIGHLANDER_TSS2, CAR.HIGHLANDERH_TSS2):
@ -97,6 +105,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 16.0 ret.steerRatio = 16.0
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.8 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.8
ret.mass = 4700. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # 4260 + 4-5 people ret.mass = 4700. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # 4260 + 4-5 people
ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.0
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_G) set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_G)
elif candidate in (CAR.HIGHLANDER, CAR.HIGHLANDERH): elif candidate in (CAR.HIGHLANDER, CAR.HIGHLANDERH):
@ -105,6 +114,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 16.0 ret.steerRatio = 16.0
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.8 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.8
ret.mass = 4607. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # mean between normal and hybrid limited ret.mass = 4607. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # mean between normal and hybrid limited
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.8
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_G) set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_G)
elif candidate in (CAR.AVALON, CAR.AVALON_2019, CAR.AVALONH_2019, CAR.AVALON_TSS2, CAR.AVALONH_TSS2): elif candidate in (CAR.AVALON, CAR.AVALON_2019, CAR.AVALONH_2019, CAR.AVALON_TSS2, CAR.AVALONH_TSS2):
@ -115,6 +125,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 14.8 # Found at https://pressroom.toyota.com/releases/2016+avalon+product+specs.download ret.steerRatio = 14.8 # Found at https://pressroom.toyota.com/releases/2016+avalon+product+specs.download
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.7983 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.7983
ret.mass = 3505. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # mean between normal and hybrid ret.mass = 3505. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # mean between normal and hybrid
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.6
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_H) set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_H)
elif candidate in (CAR.RAV4_TSS2, CAR.RAV4_TSS2_2022, CAR.RAV4H_TSS2, CAR.RAV4H_TSS2_2022): elif candidate in (CAR.RAV4_TSS2, CAR.RAV4_TSS2_2022, CAR.RAV4H_TSS2, CAR.RAV4H_TSS2_2022):
@ -123,6 +134,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 14.3 ret.steerRatio = 14.3
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.7933 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.7933
ret.mass = 3585. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # Average between ICE and Hybrid ret.mass = 3585. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # Average between ICE and Hybrid
ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.5
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_D) set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_D)
# 2019+ RAV4 TSS2 uses two different steering racks and specific tuning seems to be necessary. # 2019+ RAV4 TSS2 uses two different steering racks and specific tuning seems to be necessary.
@ -138,7 +150,8 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 13.9 ret.steerRatio = 13.9
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444 # not optimized yet tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444 # not optimized yet
ret.mass = 3060. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 3060. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.TORQUE, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=2.0, FRICTION=0.07) ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.0
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.TORQUE, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=ret.maxLateralAccel, FRICTION=0.07)
elif candidate in (CAR.LEXUS_ES_TSS2, CAR.LEXUS_ESH_TSS2, CAR.LEXUS_ESH): elif candidate in (CAR.LEXUS_ES_TSS2, CAR.LEXUS_ESH_TSS2, CAR.LEXUS_ESH):
stop_and_go = True stop_and_go = True
@ -146,6 +159,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 16.0 # not optimized ret.steerRatio = 16.0 # not optimized
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444 # not optimized yet tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444 # not optimized yet
ret.mass = 3677. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # mean between min and max ret.mass = 3677. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG # mean between min and max
ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.2
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_D) set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_D)
elif candidate == CAR.SIENNA: elif candidate == CAR.SIENNA:
@ -154,6 +168,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 15.5 ret.steerRatio = 15.5
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444
ret.mass = 4590. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 4590. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.6
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_J) set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_J)
elif candidate in (CAR.LEXUS_IS, CAR.LEXUS_RC): elif candidate in (CAR.LEXUS_IS, CAR.LEXUS_RC):
@ -177,6 +192,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 14.7 ret.steerRatio = 14.7
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444 # not optimized yet tire_stiffness_factor = 0.444 # not optimized yet
ret.mass = 4070 * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 4070 * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG
ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.0
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_C) set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_C)
elif candidate == CAR.PRIUS_TSS2: elif candidate == CAR.PRIUS_TSS2:
@ -185,6 +201,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 13.4 # True steerRatio from older prius ret.steerRatio = 13.4 # True steerRatio from older prius
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.6371 # hand-tune tire_stiffness_factor = 0.6371 # hand-tune
ret.mass = 3115. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 3115. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG
ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.0
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_N) set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_N)
elif candidate == CAR.MIRAI: elif candidate == CAR.MIRAI:
@ -193,6 +210,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
ret.steerRatio = 14.8 ret.steerRatio = 14.8
tire_stiffness_factor = 0.8 tire_stiffness_factor = 0.8
ret.mass = 4300. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 4300. * CV.LB_TO_KG + STD_CARGO_KG
ret.maxLateralAccel = 2.4
set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_C) set_lat_tune(ret.lateralTuning, LatTunes.PID_C)
elif candidate in (CAR.ALPHARD_TSS2, CAR.ALPHARDH_TSS2): elif candidate in (CAR.ALPHARD_TSS2, CAR.ALPHARDH_TSS2):

@ -50,7 +50,7 @@ def set_long_tune(tune, name):
###### LAT ###### ###### LAT ######
def set_lat_tune(tune, name, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=2.5, FRICTION=.1, use_steering_angle=True): def set_lat_tune(tune, name, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=2.5, FRICTION=0.01, use_steering_angle=True):
if name == LatTunes.TORQUE: if name == LatTunes.TORQUE:
set_torque_tune(tune, MAX_LAT_ACCEL, FRICTION) set_torque_tune(tune, MAX_LAT_ACCEL, FRICTION)
elif 'PID' in str(name): elif 'PID' in str(name):

@ -100,7 +100,6 @@ class Footnote(Enum):
@dataclass @dataclass
class ToyotaCarInfo(CarInfo): class ToyotaCarInfo(CarInfo):
package: str = "All" package: str = "All"
good_torque: bool = True
harness: Enum = Harness.toyota harness: Enum = Harness.toyota

@ -64,14 +64,17 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
elif candidate == CAR.ATLAS_MK1: elif candidate == CAR.ATLAS_MK1:
ret.mass = 2011 + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 2011 + STD_CARGO_KG
ret.wheelbase = 2.98 ret.wheelbase = 2.98
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.4
elif candidate == CAR.GOLF_MK7: elif candidate == CAR.GOLF_MK7:
ret.mass = 1397 + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 1397 + STD_CARGO_KG
ret.wheelbase = 2.62 ret.wheelbase = 2.62
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.5
elif candidate == CAR.JETTA_MK7: elif candidate == CAR.JETTA_MK7:
ret.mass = 1328 + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 1328 + STD_CARGO_KG
ret.wheelbase = 2.71 ret.wheelbase = 2.71
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.2
elif candidate == CAR.PASSAT_MK8: elif candidate == CAR.PASSAT_MK8:
ret.mass = 1551 + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 1551 + STD_CARGO_KG
@ -92,6 +95,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
elif candidate == CAR.TIGUAN_MK2: elif candidate == CAR.TIGUAN_MK2:
ret.mass = 1715 + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 1715 + STD_CARGO_KG
ret.wheelbase = 2.74 ret.wheelbase = 2.74
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.1
elif candidate == CAR.TOURAN_MK2: elif candidate == CAR.TOURAN_MK2:
ret.mass = 1516 + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 1516 + STD_CARGO_KG
@ -109,6 +113,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
elif candidate == CAR.AUDI_A3_MK3: elif candidate == CAR.AUDI_A3_MK3:
ret.mass = 1335 + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 1335 + STD_CARGO_KG
ret.wheelbase = 2.61 ret.wheelbase = 2.61
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.7
elif candidate == CAR.AUDI_Q2_MK1: elif candidate == CAR.AUDI_Q2_MK1:
ret.mass = 1205 + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 1205 + STD_CARGO_KG
@ -117,6 +122,7 @@ class CarInterface(CarInterfaceBase):
elif candidate == CAR.AUDI_Q3_MK2: elif candidate == CAR.AUDI_Q3_MK2:
ret.mass = 1623 + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 1623 + STD_CARGO_KG
ret.wheelbase = 2.68 ret.wheelbase = 2.68
ret.maxLateralAccel = 1.6
elif candidate == CAR.SEAT_ATECA_MK1: elif candidate == CAR.SEAT_ATECA_MK1:
ret.mass = 1900 + STD_CARGO_KG ret.mass = 1900 + STD_CARGO_KG

@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ LOW_SPEED_FACTOR = 200
JERK_THRESHOLD = 0.2 JERK_THRESHOLD = 0.2
def set_torque_tune(tune, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=2.5, FRICTION=.1): def set_torque_tune(tune, MAX_LAT_ACCEL=2.5, FRICTION=0.01):
tune.init('torque') tune.init('torque')
tune.torque.useSteeringAngle = True tune.torque.useSteeringAngle = True
tune.torque.kp = 1.0 / MAX_LAT_ACCEL tune.torque.kp = 1.0 / MAX_LAT_ACCEL

@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ def plannerd_thread(sm=None, pm=None):
CP = car.CarParams.from_bytes(params.get("CarParams", block=True)) CP = car.CarParams.from_bytes(params.get("CarParams", block=True))
cloudlog.info("plannerd got CarParams: %s", CP.carName) cloudlog.info("plannerd got CarParams: %s", CP.carName)
use_lanelines = not params.get_bool('EndToEndToggle') use_lanelines = False
wide_camera = params.get_bool('WideCameraOnly') wide_camera = params.get_bool('WideCameraOnly')
cloudlog.event("e2e mode", on=use_lanelines) cloudlog.event("e2e mode", on=use_lanelines)

@ -41,9 +41,9 @@
}, },
{ {
"name": "system", "name": "system",
"url": "https://commadist.azureedge.net/agnosupdate/system-8aa796767e3af57fd24e4d54280944187b8fcc04c8748f5c20fef2700be10161.img.xz", "url": "https://commadist.azureedge.net/agnosupdate/system-11fdbc9e8a9cd27f98346d7e1039bc5b3032d0e892ff95fa1258673ff1809bca.img.xz",
"hash": "b51b8247f2b926edc3a2b8242bbab52a484ae72559a3b4a55e961bf6b8d47223", "hash": "45b4719a9e580617cf840036b24fb0dcd32491edd9654d8d74c28d91ff362d36",
"hash_raw": "8aa796767e3af57fd24e4d54280944187b8fcc04c8748f5c20fef2700be10161", "hash_raw": "11fdbc9e8a9cd27f98346d7e1039bc5b3032d0e892ff95fa1258673ff1809bca",
"size": 10737418240, "size": 10737418240,
"sparse": true, "sparse": true,
"full_check": false, "full_check": false,

@ -16,11 +16,11 @@ class Proc:
power: float power: float
rtol: float = 0.05 rtol: float = 0.05
atol: float = 0.1 atol: float = 0.1
warmup: float = 3. warmup: float = 6.
PROCS = [ PROCS = [
Proc('camerad', 2.25), Proc('camerad', 2.15),
Proc('modeld', 0.95), Proc('modeld', 1.0),
Proc('dmonitoringmodeld', 0.25), Proc('dmonitoringmodeld', 0.25),
Proc('encoderd', 0.23), Proc('encoderd', 0.23),
] ]

@ -44,19 +44,19 @@ class Laikad:
ecef_pos = self.gnss_kf.x[GStates.ECEF_POS].tolist() ecef_pos = self.gnss_kf.x[GStates.ECEF_POS].tolist()
ecef_vel = self.gnss_kf.x[GStates.ECEF_VELOCITY].tolist() ecef_vel = self.gnss_kf.x[GStates.ECEF_VELOCITY].tolist()
pos_std = float(np.linalg.norm(self.gnss_kf.P[GStates.ECEF_POS])) pos_std = self.gnss_kf.P[GStates.ECEF_POS].flatten().tolist()
vel_std = float(np.linalg.norm(self.gnss_kf.P[GStates.ECEF_VELOCITY])) vel_std = self.gnss_kf.P[GStates.ECEF_VELOCITY].flatten().tolist()
bearing_deg, bearing_std = get_bearing_from_gnss(ecef_pos, ecef_vel, vel_std) bearing_deg, bearing_std = get_bearing_from_gnss(ecef_pos, ecef_vel, vel_std)
meas_msgs = [create_measurement_msg(m) for m in corrected_measurements] meas_msgs = [create_measurement_msg(m) for m in corrected_measurements]
dat = messaging.new_message("gnssMeasurements") dat = messaging.new_message("gnssMeasurements")
measurement_msg = log.GnssMeasurements.Measurement.new_message measurement_msg = log.LiveLocationKalman.Measurement.new_message
dat.gnssMeasurements = { dat.gnssMeasurements = {
"positionECEF": measurement_msg(value=ecef_pos, std=pos_std, valid=localizer_valid), "positionECEF": measurement_msg(value=ecef_pos, std=pos_std, valid=localizer_valid),
"velocityECEF": measurement_msg(value=ecef_vel, std=vel_std, valid=localizer_valid), "velocityECEF": measurement_msg(value=ecef_vel, std=vel_std, valid=localizer_valid),
"bearingDeg": measurement_msg(value=[bearing_deg], std=bearing_std, valid=localizer_valid), "bearingDeg": measurement_msg(value=[bearing_deg], std=[bearing_std], valid=localizer_valid),
"ubloxMonoTime": ublox_mono_time, "ubloxMonoTime": ublox_mono_time,
"correctedMeasurements": meas_msgs "correctedMeasurements": meas_msgs
} }
@ -77,7 +77,7 @@ class Laikad:
filter_time = self.gnss_kf.filter.filter_time filter_time = self.gnss_kf.filter.filter_time
if filter_time is None: if filter_time is None:
cloudlog.info("Init gnss kalman filter") cloudlog.info("Init gnss kalman filter")
elif (t - filter_time) > MAX_TIME_GAP: elif abs(t - filter_time) > MAX_TIME_GAP:
cloudlog.error("Time gap of over 10s detected, gnss kalman reset") cloudlog.error("Time gap of over 10s detected, gnss kalman reset")
else: else:
cloudlog.error("Gnss kalman filter state is nan") cloudlog.error("Gnss kalman filter state is nan")
@ -136,7 +136,7 @@ def get_bearing_from_gnss(ecef_pos, ecef_vel, vel_std):
ned_vel = np.einsum('ij,j ->i', converter.ned_from_ecef_matrix, ecef_vel) ned_vel = np.einsum('ij,j ->i', converter.ned_from_ecef_matrix, ecef_vel)
bearing = np.arctan2(ned_vel[1], ned_vel[0]) bearing = np.arctan2(ned_vel[1], ned_vel[0])
bearing_std = np.arctan2(vel_std, np.linalg.norm(ned_vel)) bearing_std = np.arctan2(np.linalg.norm(vel_std), np.linalg.norm(ned_vel))
return float(np.rad2deg(bearing)), float(bearing_std) return float(np.rad2deg(bearing)), float(bearing_std)

@ -17,7 +17,7 @@ from selfdrive.version import is_dirty
MAX_CACHE_SIZE = 4e9 if "CI" in os.environ else 2e9 MAX_CACHE_SIZE = 4e9 if "CI" in os.environ else 2e9
CACHE_DIR = Path("/data/scons_cache" if AGNOS else "/tmp/scons_cache") CACHE_DIR = Path("/data/scons_cache" if AGNOS else "/tmp/scons_cache")
TOTAL_SCONS_NODES = 2405 TOTAL_SCONS_NODES = 2035
MAX_BUILD_PROGRESS = 100 MAX_BUILD_PROGRESS = 100
PREBUILT = os.path.exists(os.path.join(BASEDIR, 'prebuilt')) PREBUILT = os.path.exists(os.path.join(BASEDIR, 'prebuilt'))

@ -2,18 +2,24 @@ from __future__ import annotations
import json import json
import math import math
from typing import Any, Dict, List, Optional, Tuple from typing import Any, Dict, List, Optional, Tuple, Union, cast
from common.conversions import Conversions
from common.numpy_fast import clip from common.numpy_fast import clip
from common.params import Params from common.params import Params
EARTH_MEAN_RADIUS = 6371007.2 EARTH_MEAN_RADIUS = 6371007.2
SPEED_CONVERSIONS = {
'km/h': Conversions.KPH_TO_MS,
'mph': Conversions.MPH_TO_MS,
}
class Coordinate: class Coordinate:
def __init__(self, latitude: float, longitude: float) -> None: def __init__(self, latitude: float, longitude: float) -> None:
self.latitude = latitude self.latitude = latitude
self.longitude = longitude self.longitude = longitude
self.annotations: Dict[str, float] = {}
@classmethod @classmethod
def from_mapbox_tuple(cls, t: Tuple[float, float]) -> Coordinate: def from_mapbox_tuple(cls, t: Tuple[float, float]) -> Coordinate:
@ -116,6 +122,12 @@ def string_to_direction(direction: str) -> str:
return 'none' return 'none'
def maxspeed_to_ms(maxspeed: Dict[str, Union[str, float]]) -> float:
unit = cast(str, maxspeed['unit'])
speed = cast(float, maxspeed['speed'])
return SPEED_CONVERSIONS[unit] * speed
def parse_banner_instructions(instruction: Any, banners: Any, distance_to_maneuver: float = 0.0) -> None: def parse_banner_instructions(instruction: Any, banners: Any, distance_to_maneuver: float = 0.0) -> None:
if not len(banners): if not len(banners):
return return

@ -10,11 +10,11 @@ from cereal import log
from common.api import Api from common.api import Api
from common.params import Params from common.params import Params
from common.realtime import Ratekeeper from common.realtime import Ratekeeper
from selfdrive.swaglog import cloudlog
from selfdrive.navd.helpers import (Coordinate, coordinate_from_param, from selfdrive.navd.helpers import (Coordinate, coordinate_from_param,
distance_along_geometry, distance_along_geometry, maxspeed_to_ms,
minimum_distance, minimum_distance,
parse_banner_instructions) parse_banner_instructions)
from selfdrive.swaglog import cloudlog
REROUTE_DISTANCE = 25 REROUTE_DISTANCE = 25
MANEUVER_TRANSITION_THRESHOLD = 10 MANEUVER_TRANSITION_THRESHOLD = 10
@ -110,7 +110,7 @@ class RouteEngine:
params = { params = {
'access_token': self.mapbox_token, 'access_token': self.mapbox_token,
# 'annotations': 'maxspeed', 'annotations': 'maxspeed',
'geometries': 'geojson', 'geometries': 'geojson',
'overview': 'full', 'overview': 'full',
'steps': 'true', 'steps': 'true',
@ -131,9 +131,25 @@ class RouteEngine:
self.route = r['routes'][0]['legs'][0]['steps'] self.route = r['routes'][0]['legs'][0]['steps']
self.route_geometry = [] self.route_geometry = []
maxspeed_idx = 0
maxspeeds = r['routes'][0]['legs'][0]['annotation']['maxspeed']
# Convert coordinates # Convert coordinates
for step in self.route: for step in self.route:
self.route_geometry.append([Coordinate.from_mapbox_tuple(c) for c in step['geometry']['coordinates']]) coords = []
for c in step['geometry']['coordinates']:
coord = Coordinate.from_mapbox_tuple(c)
# Last step does not have maxspeed
if (maxspeed_idx < len(maxspeeds)) and ('unknown' not in maxspeeds[maxspeed_idx]):
coord.annotations['maxspeed'] = maxspeed_to_ms(maxspeeds[maxspeed_idx])
coords.append(coord)
maxspeed_idx += 1
self.route_geometry.append(coords)
maxspeed_idx -= 1 # Every segment ends with the same coordinate as the start of the next
self.step_idx = 0 self.step_idx = 0
else: else:
@ -179,6 +195,23 @@ class RouteEngine:
msg.navInstruction.timeRemaining = total_time msg.navInstruction.timeRemaining = total_time
msg.navInstruction.timeRemainingTypical = total_time_typical msg.navInstruction.timeRemainingTypical = total_time_typical
# Speed limit
closest_idx, closest = min(enumerate(geometry), key=lambda p: p[1].distance_to(self.last_position))
if closest_idx > 0:
# If we are not past the closest point, show previous
if along_geometry < distance_along_geometry(geometry, geometry[closest_idx]):
closest = geometry[closest_idx - 1]
if 'maxspeed' in closest.annotations:
msg.navInstruction.speedLimit = closest.annotations['maxspeed']
# Speed limit sign type
if 'speedLimitSign' in step:
if step['speedLimitSign'] == 'mutcd':
msg.navInstruction.speedLimitSign = log.NavInstruction.SpeedLimitSign.mutcd
elif step['speedLimitSign'] == 'vienna':
msg.navInstruction.speedLimitSign = log.NavInstruction.SpeedLimitSign.vienna
self.pm.send('navInstruction', msg) self.pm.send('navInstruction', msg)
# Transition to next route segment # Transition to next route segment

@ -10,9 +10,8 @@ import cereal.messaging as messaging
from cereal.visionipc import VisionIpcServer, VisionStreamType from cereal.visionipc import VisionIpcServer, VisionStreamType
from common.spinner import Spinner from common.spinner import Spinner
from common.timeout import Timeout from common.timeout import Timeout
from common.transformations.camera import get_view_frame_from_road_frame, eon_f_frame_size, tici_f_frame_size, \ from common.transformations.camera import get_view_frame_from_road_frame, tici_f_frame_size, tici_d_frame_size
eon_d_frame_size, tici_d_frame_size from selfdrive.hardware import PC
from selfdrive.hardware import PC, TICI
from selfdrive.manager.process_config import managed_processes from selfdrive.manager.process_config import managed_processes
from selfdrive.test.openpilotci import BASE_URL, get_url from selfdrive.test.openpilotci import BASE_URL, get_url
from selfdrive.test.process_replay.compare_logs import compare_logs, save_log from selfdrive.test.process_replay.compare_logs import compare_logs, save_log
@ -23,14 +22,14 @@ from tools.lib.logreader import LogReader
TEST_ROUTE = "4cf7a6ad03080c90|2021-09-29--13-46-36" TEST_ROUTE = "4cf7a6ad03080c90|2021-09-29--13-46-36"
SEGMENT = 0 SEGMENT = 0
MAX_FRAMES = 20 if PC else 1300
SEND_EXTRA_INPUTS = bool(os.getenv("SEND_EXTRA_INPUTS", "0")) SEND_EXTRA_INPUTS = bool(os.getenv("SEND_EXTRA_INPUTS", "0"))
VIPC_STREAM = {"roadCameraState": VisionStreamType.VISION_STREAM_ROAD, "driverCameraState": VisionStreamType.VISION_STREAM_DRIVER, VIPC_STREAM = {"roadCameraState": VisionStreamType.VISION_STREAM_ROAD, "driverCameraState": VisionStreamType.VISION_STREAM_DRIVER,
"wideRoadCameraState": VisionStreamType.VISION_STREAM_WIDE_ROAD} "wideRoadCameraState": VisionStreamType.VISION_STREAM_WIDE_ROAD}
def get_log_fn(ref_commit, test_route):
def get_log_fn(ref_commit, test_route, tici=True): return f"{test_route}_model_tici_{ref_commit}.bz2"
return f"{test_route}_{'model_tici' if tici else 'model'}_{ref_commit}.bz2"
def replace_calib(msg, calib): def replace_calib(msg, calib):
@ -41,12 +40,15 @@ def replace_calib(msg, calib):
def model_replay(lr, frs): def model_replay(lr, frs):
spinner = Spinner() if not PC:
spinner.update("starting model replay") spinner = Spinner()
spinner.update("starting model replay")
else:
spinner = None
vipc_server = VisionIpcServer("camerad") vipc_server = VisionIpcServer("camerad")
vipc_server.create_buffers(VisionStreamType.VISION_STREAM_ROAD, 40, False, *(tici_f_frame_size if TICI else eon_f_frame_size)) vipc_server.create_buffers(VisionStreamType.VISION_STREAM_ROAD, 40, False, *(tici_f_frame_size))
vipc_server.create_buffers(VisionStreamType.VISION_STREAM_DRIVER, 40, False, *(tici_d_frame_size if TICI else eon_d_frame_size)) vipc_server.create_buffers(VisionStreamType.VISION_STREAM_DRIVER, 40, False, *(tici_d_frame_size))
vipc_server.create_buffers(VisionStreamType.VISION_STREAM_WIDE_ROAD, 40, False, *(tici_f_frame_size)) vipc_server.create_buffers(VisionStreamType.VISION_STREAM_WIDE_ROAD, 40, False, *(tici_f_frame_size))
vipc_server.start_listener() vipc_server.start_listener()
@ -76,7 +78,7 @@ def model_replay(lr, frs):
for cam_msgs in zip_longest(msgs['roadCameraState'], msgs['wideRoadCameraState'], msgs['driverCameraState']): for cam_msgs in zip_longest(msgs['roadCameraState'], msgs['wideRoadCameraState'], msgs['driverCameraState']):
# need a pair of road/wide msgs # need a pair of road/wide msgs
if TICI and None in (cam_msgs[0], cam_msgs[1]): if None in (cam_msgs[0], cam_msgs[1]):
break break
for msg in cam_msgs: for msg in cam_msgs:
@ -107,7 +109,7 @@ def model_replay(lr, frs):
recv = None recv = None
if msg.which() in ('roadCameraState', 'wideRoadCameraState'): if msg.which() in ('roadCameraState', 'wideRoadCameraState'):
if not TICI or min(frame_idxs['roadCameraState'], frame_idxs['wideRoadCameraState']) > recv_cnt['modelV2']: if min(frame_idxs['roadCameraState'], frame_idxs['wideRoadCameraState']) > recv_cnt['modelV2']:
recv = "modelV2" recv = "modelV2"
elif msg.which() == 'driverCameraState': elif msg.which() == 'driverCameraState':
recv = "driverState" recv = "driverState"
@ -118,14 +120,19 @@ def model_replay(lr, frs):
recv_cnt[recv] += 1 recv_cnt[recv] += 1
log_msgs.append(messaging.recv_one(sm.sock[recv])) log_msgs.append(messaging.recv_one(sm.sock[recv]))
spinner.update("replaying models: road %d/%d, driver %d/%d" % (frame_idxs['roadCameraState'], if spinner:
frs['roadCameraState'].frame_count, frame_idxs['driverCameraState'], frs['driverCameraState'].frame_count)) spinner.update("replaying models: road %d/%d, driver %d/%d" % (frame_idxs['roadCameraState'],
frs['roadCameraState'].frame_count, frame_idxs['driverCameraState'], frs['driverCameraState'].frame_count))
if any(frame_idxs[c] >= frs[c].frame_count for c in frame_idxs.keys()): if any(frame_idxs[c] >= frs[c].frame_count for c in frame_idxs.keys()) or frame_idxs['roadCameraState'] == MAX_FRAMES:
break break
else:
print(f'Received {frame_idxs["roadCameraState"]} frames')
finally: finally:
spinner.close() if spinner:
spinner.close()
managed_processes['modeld'].stop() managed_processes['modeld'].stop()
managed_processes['dmonitoringmodeld'].stop() managed_processes['dmonitoringmodeld'].stop()
@ -144,9 +151,8 @@ if __name__ == "__main__":
frs = { frs = {
'roadCameraState': FrameReader(get_url(TEST_ROUTE, SEGMENT, log_type="fcamera")), 'roadCameraState': FrameReader(get_url(TEST_ROUTE, SEGMENT, log_type="fcamera")),
'driverCameraState': FrameReader(get_url(TEST_ROUTE, SEGMENT, log_type="dcamera")), 'driverCameraState': FrameReader(get_url(TEST_ROUTE, SEGMENT, log_type="dcamera")),
'wideRoadCameraState': FrameReader(get_url(TEST_ROUTE, SEGMENT, log_type="ecamera"))
} }
if TICI:
frs['wideRoadCameraState'] = FrameReader(get_url(TEST_ROUTE, SEGMENT, log_type="ecamera"))
# run replay # run replay
log_msgs = model_replay(lr, frs) log_msgs = model_replay(lr, frs)
@ -156,9 +162,9 @@ if __name__ == "__main__":
if not update: if not update:
with open(ref_commit_fn) as f: with open(ref_commit_fn) as f:
ref_commit = f.read().strip() ref_commit = f.read().strip()
log_fn = get_log_fn(ref_commit, TEST_ROUTE, tici=TICI) log_fn = get_log_fn(ref_commit, TEST_ROUTE)
try: try:
cmp_log = LogReader(BASE_URL + log_fn) cmp_log = list(LogReader(BASE_URL + log_fn))[:2*MAX_FRAMES]
ignore = [ ignore = [
'logMonoTime', 'logMonoTime',
@ -167,7 +173,8 @@ if __name__ == "__main__":
'driverState.modelExecutionTime', 'driverState.modelExecutionTime',
'driverState.dspExecutionTime' 'driverState.dspExecutionTime'
] ]
tolerance = None if not PC else 1e-3 # TODO this tolerence is absurdly large
tolerance = 5e-1 if PC else None
results: Any = {TEST_ROUTE: {}} results: Any = {TEST_ROUTE: {}}
results[TEST_ROUTE]["models"] = compare_logs(cmp_log, log_msgs, tolerance=tolerance, ignore_fields=ignore) results[TEST_ROUTE]["models"] = compare_logs(cmp_log, log_msgs, tolerance=tolerance, ignore_fields=ignore)
diff1, diff2, failed = format_diff(results, ref_commit) diff1, diff2, failed = format_diff(results, ref_commit)
@ -182,13 +189,13 @@ if __name__ == "__main__":
failed = True failed = True
# upload new refs # upload new refs
if update or failed: if (update or failed) and not PC:
from selfdrive.test.openpilotci import upload_file from selfdrive.test.openpilotci import upload_file
print("Uploading new refs") print("Uploading new refs")
new_commit = get_commit() new_commit = get_commit()
log_fn = get_log_fn(new_commit, TEST_ROUTE, tici=TICI) log_fn = get_log_fn(new_commit, TEST_ROUTE)
save_log(log_fn, log_msgs) save_log(log_fn, log_msgs)
try: try:
upload_file(log_fn, os.path.basename(log_fn)) upload_file(log_fn, os.path.basename(log_fn))

@ -1 +1 @@
49e231ccf06ef35994a3ec907af959c28e3c0870 0e18bb3317437f2cad6d0a5782a9222eda655d58

@ -57,12 +57,6 @@ TogglesPanel::TogglesPanel(SettingsWindow *parent) : ListWidget(parent) {
"Upload data from the driver facing camera and help improve the driver monitoring algorithm.", "Upload data from the driver facing camera and help improve the driver monitoring algorithm.",
"../assets/offroad/icon_monitoring.png", "../assets/offroad/icon_monitoring.png",
}, },
{
"EndToEndToggle",
"\U0001f96c Disable use of lanelines (Alpha) \U0001f96c",
"In this mode openpilot will ignore lanelines and just drive how it thinks a human would.",
"../assets/offroad/icon_road.png",
},
{ {
"DisengageOnAccelerator", "DisengageOnAccelerator",
"Disengage On Accelerator Pedal", "Disengage On Accelerator Pedal",
@ -95,9 +89,6 @@ TogglesPanel::TogglesPanel(SettingsWindow *parent) : ListWidget(parent) {
auto toggle = new ParamControl(param, title, desc, icon, this); auto toggle = new ParamControl(param, title, desc, icon, this);
bool locked = params.getBool((param + "Lock").toStdString()); bool locked = params.getBool((param + "Lock").toStdString());
toggle->setEnabled(!locked); toggle->setEnabled(!locked);
if (!locked) {
connect(uiState(), &UIState::offroadTransition, toggle, &ParamControl::setEnabled);
}
addItem(toggle); addItem(toggle);
} }
} }

@ -311,24 +311,19 @@ void NvgWindow::drawLaneLines(QPainter &painter, const UIState *s) {
// paint path // paint path
QLinearGradient bg(0, height(), 0, height() / 4); QLinearGradient bg(0, height(), 0, height() / 4);
if (scene.end_to_end) { const auto &orientation = (*s->sm)["modelV2"].getModelV2().getOrientation();
const auto &orientation = (*s->sm)["modelV2"].getModelV2().getOrientation(); float orientation_future = 0;
float orientation_future = 0; if (orientation.getZ().size() > 16) {
if (orientation.getZ().size() > 16) { orientation_future = std::abs(orientation.getZ()[16]); // 2.5 seconds
orientation_future = std::abs(orientation.getZ()[16]); // 2.5 seconds
}
// straight: 112, in turns: 70
float curve_hue = fmax(70, 112 - (orientation_future * 420));
// FIXME: painter.drawPolygon can be slow if hue is not rounded
curve_hue = int(curve_hue * 100 + 0.5) / 100;
bg.setColorAt(0.0, QColor::fromHslF(148 / 360., 0.94, 0.51, 0.4));
bg.setColorAt(0.75 / 1.5, QColor::fromHslF(curve_hue / 360., 1.0, 0.68, 0.35));
bg.setColorAt(1.0, QColor::fromHslF(curve_hue / 360., 1.0, 0.68, 0.0));
} else {
bg.setColorAt(0, whiteColor());
bg.setColorAt(1, whiteColor(0));
} }
// straight: 112, in turns: 70
float curve_hue = fmax(70, 112 - (orientation_future * 420));
// FIXME: painter.drawPolygon can be slow if hue is not rounded
curve_hue = int(curve_hue * 100 + 0.5) / 100;
bg.setColorAt(0.0, QColor::fromHslF(148 / 360., 0.94, 0.51, 0.4));
bg.setColorAt(0.75 / 1.5, QColor::fromHslF(curve_hue / 360., 1.0, 0.68, 0.35));
bg.setColorAt(1.0, QColor::fromHslF(curve_hue / 360., 1.0, 0.68, 0.0));
painter.setBrush(bg); painter.setBrush(bg);
painter.drawPolygon(scene.track_vertices.v, scene.track_vertices.cnt); painter.drawPolygon(scene.track_vertices.v, scene.track_vertices.cnt);

@ -114,7 +114,7 @@ static void update_model(UIState *s, const cereal::ModelDataV2::Reader &model) {
max_distance = std::clamp((float)(lead_d - fmin(lead_d * 0.35, 10.)), 0.0f, max_distance); max_distance = std::clamp((float)(lead_d - fmin(lead_d * 0.35, 10.)), 0.0f, max_distance);
} }
max_idx = get_path_length_idx(model_position, max_distance); max_idx = get_path_length_idx(model_position, max_distance);
update_line_data(s, model_position, scene.end_to_end ? 0.9 : 0.5, 1.22, &scene.track_vertices, max_idx, false); update_line_data(s, model_position, 0.9, 1.22, &scene.track_vertices, max_idx, false);
} }
static void update_sockets(UIState *s) { static void update_sockets(UIState *s) {
@ -221,7 +221,6 @@ void UIState::updateStatus() {
if (scene.started) { if (scene.started) {
status = STATUS_DISENGAGED; status = STATUS_DISENGAGED;
scene.started_frame = sm->frame; scene.started_frame = sm->frame;
scene.end_to_end = Params().getBool("EndToEndToggle");
wide_camera = Params().getBool("WideCameraOnly"); wide_camera = Params().getBool("WideCameraOnly");
} }
started_prev = scene.started; started_prev = scene.started;

@ -107,7 +107,7 @@ typedef struct UIScene {
QPointF lead_vertices[2]; QPointF lead_vertices[2];
float light_sensor, accel_sensor, gyro_sensor; float light_sensor, accel_sensor, gyro_sensor;
bool started, ignition, is_metric, longitudinal_control, end_to_end; bool started, ignition, is_metric, longitudinal_control;
uint64_t started_frame; uint64_t started_frame;
} UIScene; } UIScene;

@ -1,25 +1,10 @@
FROM ghcr.io/commaai/openpilot-base-cl:latest FROM ghcr.io/commaai/openpilot-base-cl:latest
RUN apt-get update && apt-get install -y --no-install-recommends\ RUN apt-get update && apt-get install -y --no-install-recommends\
apt-utils \
unzip \
tar \
curl \
xz-utils \
dbus \
gcc-arm-none-eabi \
tmux \ tmux \
vim \ vim \
lsb-core \
libx11-6 \
&& rm -rf /var/lib/apt/lists/* && rm -rf /var/lib/apt/lists/*
ENV NVIDIA_VISIBLE_DEVICES all
ENV NVIDIA_DRIVER_CAPABILITIES graphics,utility,compute
ENV QTWEBENGINE_DISABLE_SANDBOX 1
RUN dbus-uuidgen > /etc/machine-id
# get same tmux config used on NEOS for debugging # get same tmux config used on NEOS for debugging
RUN cd $HOME && \ RUN cd $HOME && \
curl -O https://raw.githubusercontent.com/commaai/eon-neos-builder/master/devices/eon/home/.tmux.conf curl -O https://raw.githubusercontent.com/commaai/eon-neos-builder/master/devices/eon/home/.tmux.conf

Loading…
Cancel
Save